Ohio to switch to 1 drug for lethal injectionProfessor Deborah Denno in The Associated Press, November 13, 2009
COLUMBUS, Ohio — Ohio on Friday became the first state to adopt a procedure for lethal injections that uses one drug, a method never before tried on U.S. inmates.
The state filed papers in U.S. District Court saying it has decided to switch from a three-drug cocktail to a single injection of thiopental sodium into a vein. A separate two-drug muscle injection will be available as a backup.
The decision comes two months after an Ohio death row inmate walked away from an unsuccessful execution and subsequent executions were put on hold.
Several states have faced similar challenges, but Ohio is the first to drop the three-drug approach in favor of one dose.
Richard Dieter, director of the nonprofit Death Penalty Information Center, said the method has never been attempted on humans but has been used to euthanize animals.
"Unfortunately, this is really going to be an experiment," he said.
"They're human subjects and they're not willingly part of this. This is experimenting with the unknown, and that always raises concerns."
The U.S. Supreme Court upheld the constitutionality of lethal injection last year, but Ohio's new system is substantially different from the three-drug process the court examined. In its ruling, the court noted that the single-drug method had never been tested and wasn't being used anywhere.
That means Ohio could be opening itself to new litigation, said Deborah Denno, a law professor at Fordham University in New York and lethal injection expert.
"The inmates who are going to be executed could challenge the constitutionality of what's being raised in Ohio," Denno said Friday.
The death penalty has been on hold in Ohio while the state developed new policies. The update follows a botched execution on Sept. 15 that was halted when executioners couldn't find a suitable vein on inmate Romell Broom.
Broom, who was convicted of kidnapping, raping and killing a 14-year old girl in 1984, complained in an affidavit following the execution attempt that his executioners painfully hit muscle and bone during as many as 18 attempts to reach a vein.
The state said in a court filing last month it was having a hard time finding medical personnel willing to consult about injection because of professional and ethical rules.
The rules — which generally prohibit doctors, nurses and others from involvement in capital punishment — were deterring such personnel from speaking publicly or privately about alternatives to the state's lethal injection process.
Ohio has put 32 people to death since 1999, when executions resumed in the state.